Natrol Melatonin 5 mg Tablets
Melatonin 5 mg · 60 standard tablets
Melatonin 5 mg; B6 10 mg; calcium 60 mg per label serving.
- Amount
- Melatonin 5 mg; B6 10 mg; calcium 60 mg
- Format
- Tablets
- Review basis
- Label-based analysis
Good fit
Adults who already want this strength and a standard tablet, with added B6 accounted for.
Consider another option
You want a lower strength, no added B6, timed release, or a fix for persistent insomnia.
The product, at a glance
Amounts for the reviewed label serving.
- Reviewed variant
- Melatonin 5 mg · 60 standard tablets
- Label serving
- 1 tablet
- Servings per reviewed pack
- 60
- Ingredients per label serving
- Melatonin 5 mg; B6 10 mg; calcium 60 mg
- Other ingredients
- Microcrystalline Cellulose, Maltodextrin, Stearic Acid, Cellulose Gum, Silicon Dioxide, Magnesium Stearate
- Storage
- Store in a cool, dry place
Label sources & rating context
~ means approximate; — means no published value in this record. Customer ratings are the named publisher’s snapshot and may include multiple sizes or earlier formulas. The Supplement Explained Score is our source-reviewed editorial assessment out of 25, separate from customer stars. Compare the five criteria and the same intended use; the total is not a clinical ranking. Prices are dated USD offer snapshots; cost uses the reviewed pack and label serving.
- Label clarity: 5/5
- Evidence transfer: 3/5
- Safety fit: 3/5
- Quality proof: 2/5
- Value fit: 3/5
On this pageTable of Contents
- 1Supplement Explained Score
- 2Label facts at a glance
- 3Is this the Natrol formula you mean to buy?
- 4What does melatonin research say about this tablet?
- 5Does the label fit your bedtime routine?
- 6Who should pause before buying?
- 7Which melatonin version is on the label?
- 8How much use does the bottle actually provide?
- 9What should you compare before choosing 5 mg?
- 10FAQ
Our editorial assessment
Supplement Explained Score
16/25
Natrol Melatonin 5 mg Tablets · Melatonin 5 mg · 60 standard tablets
Five equally weighted criteria, with a product-specific reason for every point. This is a buying-decision assessment, separate from customer stars and personal medical suitability.
- Label clarity 5/5
- Reviewed Melatonin 5 mg · 60 standard tablets: 1 tablet; 60 label servings. Melatonin 5 mg; B6 10 mg; calcium 60 mg.
- Evidence transfer 3/5
- Melatonin is better supported for certain timing problems than chronic insomnia; 5 mg is not automatically better than lower amounts.
- Safety fit 3/5
- Next-day drowsiness, sedative combinations and 10 mg added B6 deserve attention; long-term use is not established safe for everyone.
- Quality proof 2/5
- No independent finished-tablet potency record was verified for the standard 5 mg/B6 formula.
- Value fit 3/5
- One tablet is easy to count, but its added B6 makes it less simple than a melatonin-only option.
Review basis: Published labels, manufacturer/retailer information, clinical sources and exact-product quality records where available. We did not buy, personally use or laboratory-test this product for this assessment.
Reviewed · Method v2.0 · How we assign points
Sources behind this score
Product labels and independent directory records identify a formula or testing scope. Clinical references concern ingredients or studied regimens unless the explanation explicitly matches the finished formula.
Is this the Natrol formula you mean to buy?
This is the 5 mg standard tablet with added B6 and calcium. Its main advantage is a simple one-tablet format if that strength already fits your sleep-timing plan. The added nutrients are not evidence that it works better than melatonin alone.
Natrol also sells gummies, fast-dissolve tablets and timed-release products. Those are different format choices, not interchangeable versions of this tablet. A standard tablet should not be assumed to provide timed release; compare the release description and full ingredient panel, not just the melatonin number.
What does melatonin research say about this tablet?
Melatonin research supports some sleep-timing and circadian uses, but strong support for chronic insomnia is lacking, according to NCCIH. Those findings concern the ingredient, not a demonstrated benefit from this particular combination.
The listed sources do not identify a clinical trial of this exact formula. There is therefore no basis to credit its B6 and calcium additions with better sleep, or to claim it beats another melatonin format. A label tells you what the product is intended to contain; it does not demonstrate a comparative benefit.
Useful expectations are narrower than a promise to solve every sleep complaint. Decide whether sleep timing is the reason you are considering melatonin before choosing a bottle. Our melatonin guide provides background for that comparison. Extra ingredients should not make an otherwise unsuitable strength or format more persuasive.
Does the label fit your bedtime routine?
The retailer’s label directions say one tablet before bedtime; that is the package instruction, not a recommendation that everyone needs this strength. Timing and next-day grogginess deserve attention before considering a higher amount.
Choose based on the routine you actually want to follow. This is a conventional tablet, so it is not the same convenience choice as a gummy or a product labeled fast-dissolve. If swallowing a tablet is the main obstacle, comparing formats is more relevant than increasing the strength. The reviewed information does not establish that this tablet can be used interchangeably with those other formats.
The label’s broad bedtime instruction also does not settle every timing question. Read our guide to when to take melatonin for context. Someone unsure about timing or their goal should resolve that uncertainty first, rather than treating the amount on the front of the bottle as the answer.
Who should pause before buying?
This is not a casual purchase for children, people who are pregnant or breastfeeding, or anyone taking medicines; professional advice comes first. A familiar brand name does not replace a review of suitability for the individual.
NCCIH lists sleepiness, headache, dizziness, and nausea as possible side effects. Short-term safety is better understood than long-term safety.
Added B6 deserves a separate check. NIH’s Office of Dietary Supplements notes that excessive B6 intake can damage nerves. Compare the B6 in multivitamins, B-complex products, and other supplements with the amount in this tablet. That is a warning about excess intake, not evidence that this particular tablet causes nerve damage. The addition is also not a reason to use this melatonin product as a B6 supplement.
Which melatonin version is on the label?
Confirm 5 mg, standard tablets and the added 10 mg of B6. A gummy, fast-dissolve tablet or timed-release version can differ in both ingredients and how it fits a sleep-timing plan.
A higher front-label dose is not a quality measure. Check the current ingredient panel, expiration date and any product-specific testing documentation. Compare the same dosage form before treating a larger bottle as the same product.
How much use does the bottle actually provide?
The bottle provides 60 labeled servings, or 60 days at one tablet per day. To compare value, divide the displayed bottle price by 60; keep delivery charges and tax outside that calculation.
That is a one-tablet daily burden under the retailer’s directions. When comparing a different format, check how many pieces make one labeled serving rather than comparing tablet or gummy counts alone. A larger bottle may lower cost per serving, but a matched formula and serving size are needed for a like-for-like comparison.
For less frequent use, the bottle lasts longer on the calendar, but that does not make its effectiveness greater. A low price also does not solve a mismatch in strength, added nutrients, or release format. If you do not want B6 in your sleep supplement, the extra ingredient is not added value merely because it comes in the same bottle.
Dated price check: HerbsPro listed the reviewed package at $8.94 on , before delivery, tax or optional discounts. This is a snapshot, not a lowest-price claim.
Comparable cost: About $0.15 per labeled day, using 60 days of supply. This is a supply calculation, not a recommended treatment duration.
Check current price at HerbsPro
Affiliate link: we may earn a commission. Confirm the package size and current label.
What should you compare before choosing 5 mg?
The two clearest alternatives are a lower-strength, melatonin-only standard tablet and a melatonin-only fast-dissolve tablet. Both address concrete reasons to pass on this formula without assuming a different brand is inherently better.
A lower-strength, melatonin-only tablet is the simpler comparison if you do not already want 5 mg or are avoiding added B6. Check the actual strength and serving size. Melatonin-only describes a simpler active-ingredient formula, not proof of better results.
A melatonin-only fast-dissolve tablet is a format comparison for someone who dislikes swallowing standard tablets. Verify its ingredients and directions rather than borrowing this product’s details. A dissolving format should not be treated as evidence of faster sleep or as timed release.
If your real question is whether to buy melatonin or magnesium, start with our melatonin vs. magnesium comparison, not the size or price of this bottle. That is a different purchasing question from choosing among melatonin formats.
Related formula reviews: Life Extension Melatonin 3 mg. Compare the full label; these are not automatically equivalent substitutes.
FAQ
Can I split this tablet instead of buying a lower strength?
The reviewed information does not confirm that the tablet is scored or suitable for splitting. A clearly labeled lower-strength product is a more straightforward purchase than relying on an unverified fraction of this tablet.
Is this suitable for a vegetarian or an allergen-restricted diet?
The reviewed facts do not verify those claims for this variant. Check the exact package’s full ingredient list and allergen statement; claims about another Natrol format are not interchangeable.
Does the calcium make it a useful calcium supplement?
Calcium is an added nutrient in this formula, but the product is being compared as melatonin. Its presence does not establish that it meets your calcium needs or provides a sleep advantage.
Is a 60-count bottle a good choice for occasional use?
Consider the bottle’s expiration date and how much you expect to use. The daily-use calculation is not a schedule you need to follow, and unused tablets are not automatically a bargain.
What if the delivered label differs from the retail listing?
Recheck the strength, added nutrients, format, and serving size before treating it as the reviewed product. Use that package’s actual label for comparisons rather than assuming the retail listing describes a newer or different formula.
References
- Reviewed retailer package and label
- NCCIH: Melatonin — What You Need To Know
- NIH Office of Dietary Supplements: Vitamin B6 Fact Sheet for Health Professionals
Label and listing checked October 2, 2026. Document-based review, not a hands-on test. Product versions and prices can change.
Editorial information
Continue your decision
If this product is not an obvious fit, use one of these routes instead of leaving the decision unfinished.
- All product analyses Browse the full product analysis library for alternatives and category comparisons.
- Supplement Explained Score See how label clarity, evidence transfer, safety fit, quality proof, and value fit are scored.
- Interaction checklist Check common combination risks before stacking supplements or medications.
- How we review evidence Understand how editorial evidence claims, uncertainty, and safety language are handled.